Based on Leiden_lineage_L1, cells at the top of this cluster are cluster 21.
This cluster expresses WT1, PLIN2 - are they adipocytes?
If not clear, merge cluster 21 with cluster 2 (share more marker genes)
Based on Leiden_lineage_L1, cells at the top of this cluster are cluster 21.
This cluster expresses WT1, PLIN2 - are they adipocytes?
If not clear, merge cluster 21 with cluster 2 (share more marker genes)
Refer to resolution Leiden Lineage L1.
These submucosal fibroblasts could be divided in two clusters: cluster 2 and cluster 8:
Cluster 2 has high expression of SFRP2, C3, EFEMP1, CFD, FBLN2, among others. Present in intestinal biopsies.
However, cluster 8 has high expression of C7, KCNN3, PDGFRL. Potentially, these could be fibroblasts from deeper layers
Split in two clusters, the one belonging to the lamina propria fibroblasts (cluster 6_Leiden lineage L1) and the other belonging to the submucosal (cluster 2_Leiden_lineage_L1)
Both vascular endothelial cells could be annotated as Lymphatic endothelium (CCL21, LYVE1, MMRN1). However, there is an heterogeneity within this cluster, although I don't think the current separation is correct.
Based on Leiden_lineage_L2, cluster 13_3 expresses specifically NTS and ACKR4, is this a subtype of lymphatic endothelial cells?
I think pericytes and SMCs are overclustered.
In my opinion, the clusters in "Leiden_Lineage_L1" of these cells make more sense.
Based on that resolution, clusters would be annotated as:
- Cluster 15: Contractile pericytes (RERGL, KCNA5, RGS5)
- Cluster 16: Pericytes (HIGD1B, STEAP4, CD36)
- Cluster 18: SMCs GREM2+ (seen in Kong et al, doi: 10.1016/j.immuni.2023.01.002., although for them they are myofibroblasts)
- Cluster 11: SMCs as they are now (SOSTDC1, NPNT, HHIP, MYOCD)
Maybe there could be more granularity in the pericytes, it could be helpful if someone knows more marker genes. If not, I would just have two clusters of pericytes
Based on the Annotation excel file, SMC Inner Muscle Cells should be FOXF2+, MORN5+, but this cluster is not
Specific expression of ADARB2 and KCNQ3, but I'm not sure about them being angiogenic pericytes.
Another good marker of angiogenic pericytes is HIGD1B, but its expression is not limited to this cluster
OPN4 and BMP8A seem to differentiate well this cluster.
But are they markers of "Pericytes secretory"?
Expression seems quite sparse, is this cluster worthy?
Some of these are RGS5+ NOTCH3. Are they pericytes?
They would correspond to cluster 17 from Leiden_lineage_L1
I'm not sure that this subclusterization of glial cells is correct. I coudn't find any marker that clearly separates each of the subyptes, and the markers we had from the Annotation grup do not follow this clusterization.
Which granularity would you like to reach at this stage? I might suggest having just one cluster of Glia (NRXN1, S100B) truly reliable
Very few cells, located in the UMAP with the S1 fibroblasts...
Why are they glia muscularis propria and not just glia?
Epithelial cells
Overclustered, this cluster does not add more information. Could be merged with S2b fibs (they express NRG1).
This cluster expresses NPY and NRG1, markers of S2b/crypt top
This cluster expresses VSTM2A, characterising them as S2a/bottom crypt
Based on Leiden_lineage_L1, cells at the top of this cluster are cluster 21.
This cluster expresses WT1, PLIN2 - are they adipocytes?
If not clear, merge cluster 21 with cluster 2 (share more marker genes)
Refer to resolution Leiden Lineage L1.
These submucosal fibroblasts could be divided in two clusters: cluster 2 and cluster 8:
Cluster 2 has high expression of SFRP2, C3, EFEMP1, CFD, FBLN2, among others. Present in intestinal biopsies.
However, cluster 8 has high expression of C7, KCNN3, PDGFRL. Potentially, these could be fibroblasts from deeper layers
Split in two clusters, the one belonging to the lamina propria fibroblasts (cluster 6_Leiden lineage L1) and the other belonging to the submucosal (cluster 2_Leiden_lineage_L1)
Both vascular endothelial cells could be annotated as Lymphatic endothelium (CCL21, LYVE1, MMRN1). However, there is an heterogeneity within this cluster, although I don't think the current separation is correct.
Based on Leiden_lineage_L2, cluster 13_3 expresses specifically NTS and ACKR4, is this a subtype of lymphatic endothelial cells?
I think pericytes and SMCs are overclustered.
In my opinion, the clusters in "Leiden_Lineage_L1" of these cells make more sense.
Based on that resolution, clusters would be annotated as:
- Cluster 15: Contractile pericytes (RERGL, KCNA5, RGS5)
- Cluster 16: Pericytes (HIGD1B, STEAP4, CD36)
- Cluster 18: SMCs GREM2+ (seen in Kong et al, doi: 10.1016/j.immuni.2023.01.002., although for them they are myofibroblasts)
- Cluster 11: SMCs as they are now (SOSTDC1, NPNT, HHIP, MYOCD)
Maybe there could be more granularity in the pericytes, it could be helpful if someone knows more marker genes. If not, I would just have two clusters of pericytes
Based on the Annotation excel file, SMC Inner Muscle Cells should be FOXF2+, MORN5+, but this cluster is not
Specific expression of ADARB2 and KCNQ3, but I'm not sure about them being angiogenic pericytes.
Another good marker of angiogenic pericytes is HIGD1B, but its expression is not limited to this cluster
OPN4 and BMP8A seem to differentiate well this cluster.
But are they markers of "Pericytes secretory"?
Expression seems quite sparse, is this cluster worthy?
Some of these are RGS5+ NOTCH3. Are they pericytes?
They would correspond to cluster 17 from Leiden_lineage_L1
I'm not sure that this subclusterization of glial cells is correct. I coudn't find any marker that clearly separates each of the subyptes, and the markers we had from the Annotation grup do not follow this clusterization.
Which granularity would you like to reach at this stage? I might suggest having just one cluster of Glia (NRXN1, S100B) truly reliable
Very few cells, located in the UMAP with the S1 fibroblasts...
Why are they glia muscularis propria and not just glia?
Epithelial cells
Overclustered, this cluster does not add more information. Could be merged with S2b fibs (they express NRG1).
This cluster expresses NPY and NRG1, markers of S2b/crypt top
This cluster expresses VSTM2A, characterising them as S2a/bottom crypt
Agree with changing the name to Intestinal Stem Cells.
In addition, this cluster is clearly separated in two in the UMAP: small intestinal ISC and colonic ISC. Might it be worth splitting this cluster in two?
This cluster include goblet cells from small intestine and large intestine (split in the UMAP) and mature goblet cells, with high expression of TFF1+.
I agree with Ángela Sanzo and I would also split clusters 6 and 11, but also consider splitting cluster 12 (from Leiden lineage 1), and indicate the origin of these cells (small intestine or large intestine)
High expression of TFF1, indicating mature state of goblet cells.
I would change "Secretory Goblet Cells Mature" to "Goblet cells mature" and indicate whether this cluster is from small intestine or large intestine samples
High expression of AQP8, indicating top-crypt location and late differentiation
I agree with separating EEC N cells and Enterochromaffin cells. They correspond to cluster 21 in Leiden_Lineage_L1, but only N cells (small intestine) express NTS.
This highlights a major comment in the epithelial subset: it might be helpful to split small intestine and large intestine samples
Enteroendocrine cells refers to a larger cell type resolution. This cells seem to share expression of genes such as NTS with EEC N cell cluster. I would suggest to merge.
Tuft cells are secretory per definition. I would just annotate them as "Tuft cells" instead of "Secretory Tuft cells". The same would apply for Goblet cells or Paneth cells.
Agree with changing the name to Intestinal Stem Cells.
In addition, this cluster is clearly separated in two in the UMAP: small intestinal ISC and colonic ISC. Might it be worth splitting this cluster in two?
This cluster include goblet cells from small intestine and large intestine (split in the UMAP) and mature goblet cells, with high expression of TFF1+.
I agree with Ángela Sanzo and I would also split clusters 6 and 11, but also consider splitting cluster 12 (from Leiden lineage 1), and indicate the origin of these cells (small intestine or large intestine)
High expression of TFF1, indicating mature state of goblet cells.
I would change "Secretory Goblet Cells Mature" to "Goblet cells mature" and indicate whether this cluster is from small intestine or large intestine samples
High expression of AQP8, indicating top-crypt location and late differentiation
I agree with separating EEC N cells and Enterochromaffin cells. They correspond to cluster 21 in Leiden_Lineage_L1, but only N cells (small intestine) express NTS.
This highlights a major comment in the epithelial subset: it might be helpful to split small intestine and large intestine samples
Enteroendocrine cells refers to a larger cell type resolution. This cells seem to share expression of genes such as NTS with EEC N cell cluster. I would suggest to merge.
Tuft cells are secretory per definition. I would just annotate them as "Tuft cells" instead of "Secretory Tuft cells". The same would apply for Goblet cells or Paneth cells.